Split Ring Pliers Review: Texas Tackle vs. The Competition

This review dives deep into the changing quality of Texas Tackle split ring pliers, comparing the current model to its highly-regarded predecessors. For years, Texas Tackle pliers have been a staple for anglers, known for their robust build and smooth operation. However, recent changes in manufacturing have sparked concerns about a significant decline in quality. This review will detail the author's firsthand experience with both the old and new pliers, focusing on the differences in material, build, and overall performance across a range of split ring sizes. We'll explore whether the price point still justifies the purchase, and offer alternatives for anglers seeking reliable and durable split ring pliers.The comparison will examine the handling, leverage, and ease of use for various tasks, highlighting both the strengths and weaknesses of the updated pliers. We'll discuss the impact of the thinner design and potentially compromised durability, and explore whether the lighter weight is a beneficial change or a contributing factor to the overall reduced effectiveness. Ultimately, this review aims to provide anglers with the information needed to make an informed decision when choosing split ring pliers, helping them determine whether the current Texas Tackle model lives up to its legacy or if alternative brands offer better value.

Read more: Top 5 Fishing Pliers for Effortless Split Ring Removal

The Decline of Texas Tackle Split Ring Pliers

I've been a loyal user of Texas Tackle split ring pliers for years. They've been my go-to for countless lure modifications, and their quality has always been exceptional. However, my recent purchase revealed a significant decline in quality. The new pliers are noticeably thinner and flimsier than their predecessors, lacking the robust build and durable coating I've come to expect.

Close-up comparison of the old and new Texas Tackle pliers, highlighting the difference in thickness.
Close-up comparison of the old and new Texas Tackle pliers, highlighting the difference in thickness.

The metal itself feels cheaper and more prone to bending. The handles are smaller and less comfortable to grip. The jaw tips are bulkier, limiting their versatility on smaller rings. This is a huge disappointment, especially considering the price remains relatively high.

A side-by-side view of the pliers, showing the thinner handles and overall construction of the new model.
A side-by-side view of the pliers, showing the thinner handles and overall construction of the new model.

This isn't just a minor variation; it's a substantial downgrade in build quality and functionality. Texas Tackle has significantly reduced the amount of material used, impacting both durability and performance. It's a stark contrast to the original pliers I've relied on for years.

Detailed shot comparing the jaw tips of both pliers, showcasing the bulkier design of the newer model.
Detailed shot comparing the jaw tips of both pliers, showcasing the bulkier design of the newer model.

Performance Comparison: Size and Functionality

I tested both the old and new pliers with a range of split rings, from ultra-light trout sizes to larger saltwater rings. The original Texas Tackle pliers handled all sizes with ease, demonstrating their versatility and efficiency. The new, thinner pliers, struggled significantly with the smaller rings, and even the larger ones felt less secure.

A variety of split rings of different sizes being shown.
A variety of split rings of different sizes being shown.

The lighter weight of the new pliers is noticeable, which, in itself, is not necessarily a negative. But combined with the thinner material, the overall feel and performance is dramatically less effective. It impacts the leverage needed for opening larger rings, and the overall feel is less controlled.

Demonstration of the old pliers effortlessly handling a small split ring.
Demonstration of the old pliers effortlessly handling a small split ring.

It's not just about the size of the rings; the new pliers lack the smooth, controlled action of their predecessors. Opening and closing rings requires more effort and precision, leading to a less efficient workflow.

Hand comparison of the weight difference between the old and new pliers.
Hand comparison of the weight difference between the old and new pliers.

Alternative Options and Overall Conclusion

While the original Texas Tackle pliers remain superior for their robust build and smooth operation, there are other brands worth considering. The Zoran pliers, for instance, offer a comparable level of performance and build quality. For larger rings and heavier-duty tasks, a larger, more powerful plier is essential.

Comparison of the old Texas Tackle pliers and the Zoran pliers
Comparison of the old Texas Tackle pliers and the Zoran pliers

The new Texas Tackle pliers, unfortunately, fall short in many aspects, compromising their overall value and performance. Their reduced material, thinner design, and bulkier jaw tips significantly impact their versatility and effectiveness.

Demonstration of the old pliers easily handling a large split ring.
Demonstration of the old pliers easily handling a large split ring.

Overall, I strongly recommend sticking with the original Texas Tackle pliers if you can find them. Otherwise, explore alternative brands offering similar durability and functionality. Don't waste your money on the current iteration of Texas Tackle split ring pliers.

The reviewer emphasizing the recommendation to purchase the older Texas Tackle pliers.
The reviewer emphasizing the recommendation to purchase the older Texas Tackle pliers.