This in-depth comparison analyzes the Shimano Vanford and Vanquish spinning reels, two popular choices among anglers with varying budgets and experience levels. We delve into the nuanced differences between these reels, examining their performance, build quality, and overall feel to help you determine which model best suits your needs. We'll explore key distinctions, including bearing counts, body materials (magnesium vs. CI4+), manufacturing location (Japan vs. Malaysia), and the impact these factors have on smoothness, drag performance, and overall longevity. We also compare the reels against competitors like the Daiwa Luvias and Shimano Twin Power to provide a broader perspective on their position within the market.This review explores the performance variations between the 2000 and 2500 sizes of both reels, highlighting surprising inconsistencies and recommending specific sizes based on observed smoothness and operational quality. We address the significant price difference between the Vanford and Vanquish, considering whether the premium justifies the upgrade. Finally, we discuss the Vanford's surprising synergy with the Abu Garcia Eradicator rod, showcasing a compelling pairing for anglers seeking a well-balanced and aesthetically pleasing setup. Our comprehensive comparison aims to provide you with the information necessary to make an informed decision based on your individual fishing style and budget.
Read more: 5 Best Electric Fishing Reels of 2024
Vanford vs. Vanquish: The Feel Factor
The core question: Does the Vanford feel as good as the Vanquish? For seasoned anglers accustomed to high-end gear, the answer is likely no. The Vanquish boasts a noticeably smoother, less resistant feel, with reduced startup inertia. Even the retrieval, despite shared gears, feels distinct.
The drag sound also differs significantly between the two reels. This subtle yet perceptible difference highlights the nuances in build quality and engineering between the two models. The Vanquish's more refined feel reflects its higher price point and sophisticated design.
Budget-Friendly Anglers' Perspective
However, for those primarily using budget reels (under $100), the Vanford offers an impressive upgrade. The difference between the Vanford and Vanquish might not be as readily apparent to these anglers. The Vanford delivers a substantial improvement in performance without the hefty price tag of the Vanquish.
Considering the Vanford's more accessible price, it presents excellent value for its performance and features. It's a solid choice for anglers looking to step up their gear without breaking the bank.
Key Differences: Bearings and Body Material
The Vanquish includes four extra bearings compared to the Vanford: two on the spool and one each on the main shaft and oscillation gear. While the reviewer couldn't definitively confirm a tangible difference in feel from these extra bearings, they plan to conduct further testing.
A significant difference lies in the body material: the Vanquish boasts a magnesium body, while the Vanford uses Shimano's CI4+ plastic. Although both are high-quality materials, the magnesium body of the Vanquish likely contributes to its tighter gear tolerances and distinct feel during retrieval.
Manufacturing and Assembly: Japan vs. Malaysia
The Vanquish is made in Japan, while the Vanford is manufactured in Malaysia. The reviewer believes that Japanese assembly contributes to superior quality control and precision, resulting in a more refined and consistent product.
This difference in manufacturing location highlights the potential impact on the overall reel performance and longevity. While the Vanford offers exceptional value, the Vanquish benefits from the reputation and precision associated with Japanese manufacturing.
2020 Vanford vs. Older Vanford Models
The reviewer compares the 2020 Vanford to its predecessor. The newer model shows improvements in smoothness, quietness, and tolerances. The line roller bearing is also purportedly improved, though the reviewer hasn't experienced issues with older models.
Despite the enhancements, the reviewer finds no perceptible difference in resistance and startup inertia. The older model already performed exceptionally well in these areas, leaving little room for improvement in the newer iteration.
Size Matters: 2500 vs. 2000
Significant differences exist between the 2500 and 2000 sizes of both reels. The 2500 Vanford exhibits smoother gears, quieter operation, tighter tolerances, and less free play compared to its predecessor. The reviewer notes that the 2000 size reels, however, exhibit a roughness not found in the 2500 size.
This roughness, also present in older Stradic CI4+ models, seems to stem from the oscillation gear. The reviewer recommends the 2500 size due to its smoother operation and potentially higher durability.
Vanford vs. Daiwa Luvias
The Vanford is compared to the Daiwa Luvias. While the Luvias is made in Japan and generally more expensive, the reviewer prefers the Vanford (especially in the 2500 size) due to its warm oscillation gear and superior line management. The longer spool and lip design of the Shimano reel are highlighted.
The 2000 size Luvias, however, stands out for its exceptional smoothness. Though resistance might be higher in the 2000 size compared to the 2500, the Luvias' smoothness is remarkable. The reviewer acknowledges that this smoothness might overshadow other factors like resistance for some anglers.
Vanford vs. Shimano Twin Power
The Vanford is compared against the Shimano Twin Power. The Twin Power, despite missing the same two bearings as the Vanford (compared to the Vanquish), feels significantly different. The Twin Power is described as buttery smooth, lacking the roughness found in the Vanford.
This comparison raises questions about the consistency of Shimano's internal components and assembly processes across different reel models. The Twin Power’s superior smoothness, despite shared components, strongly suggests significant variances in either the oscillation gear itself or assembly techniques.
Vanford vs. Daiwa Legalis/Exceler: The 2000 Size Dilemma
The reviewer addresses the comparison of the 2000 size Vanford with Daiwa's budget options, like Legalis and Exceler. While the Vanford offers weight advantages, improvements in other areas are less pronounced, especially regarding resistance.
The persistent roughness in the smaller Vanford size remains a drawback, unlike Daiwa's consistently smooth budget reels. The reviewer emphasizes that the noticeable weight difference is a significant factor in this comparison.
Vanford and Abu Garcia Eradicator: A Perfect Match
A compelling reason to choose the 2000 size Vanford: its exceptional compatibility with the Abu Garcia Eradicator rod. The aesthetics, weight balance, and overall feel combine seamlessly, creating a near-perfect synergy.
This ideal pairing elevates the Vanford's appeal, particularly for anglers already using the Eradicator rod. The aesthetic and functional harmony between the two is a strong incentive for purchasing the Vanford.
Conclusion: Which Reel Reigns Supreme?
The choice between the Vanford and Vanquish largely depends on the angler's experience level and budget. The Vanquish offers superior smoothness and a more refined feel, justifying its higher price for experienced anglers. The Vanford, however, provides an exceptional upgrade for budget-conscious anglers.
The 2000-size Vanford falls short due to roughness issues, making the Daiwa Luvias or Legalis more appealing in that size. The 2500 size Vanford presents a better value proposition, offering noticeable improvements over its predecessor and budget alternatives. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual priorities and preferences.