Choosing the right wading boots is crucial for any serious angler, impacting both comfort and performance on the water. This detailed comparison pits two industry giants against each other: the Orvis Pro BOA and the Simms G4 Pro wading boots. Both models were rigorously tested in real-world fishing conditions, focusing on comfort, durability, features, and ease of use. This review delves into the nuances of each boot, highlighting key differences in design, materials, and functionality to help you make an informed decision.We'll examine the pros and cons of each boot's closure system – the innovative BOA system versus traditional laces – and explore the importance of proper sizing. Furthermore, the comparison includes a critical assessment of additional features such as gaiter attachment points and overall construction quality. Ultimately, we aim to provide a clear and comprehensive picture of these two top contenders, enabling you to select the wading boot that best suits your individual needs and preferences.
Pros And Cons
- Unbelievably comfortable
- Feel better made
- Much stronger
- Feels like a hiking boot
- Easy to get on and off
- Requires bending over to do laces (mentioned as a problem with the reviewer's size)
- No clip for gator
Read more: Top 5 Fishing Waders of 2024
Comfort and Fit
The Orvis Pro BOA and Simms G4 Pro wading boots were both tested for comfort during fishing trips. The Simms boots were found to be significantly more comfortable than the Orvis boots, described as unbelievably comfortable. This was attributed to a better overall design and superior materials.
The reviewer noted that the Simms boots felt better made and stronger, resembling a hiking boot more than the Orvis boots. Size consistency is also a factor. The reviewer wears a UK size 10 in regular shoes but found a UK size 11 Simms boot to be perfect, recommending buying one size up from your regular shoe size.
BOA vs. Laces: The Closure System
A key difference is the closure system. The Simms G4 Pro utilizes laces, while the Orvis Pro BOA features a BOA closure system. The reviewer initially found lacing the Simms boots cumbersome, especially while bending over. However, after switching to the BOA system on the Orvis boots, they stated that they will never go back to laces.
The ease and speed of the BOA closure system were highlighted as a major advantage, especially for getting the boots on and off quickly. While long-term durability of the BOA system is unknown, the immediate convenience is highly valued.
Gator Attachment and Other Features
The Simms G4 Pro lacks a clip for attaching wading gaiters, unlike the Orvis boots. The Orvis boots have a convenient clip that securely holds the gaiter in place throughout the day. This detail is appreciated for added functionality.
The reviewer also mentions the possibility of a new Simms G4 with BOA closure. The reviewer expresses interest in trying this potential newer model from Simms.
Sizing and Final Verdict
Sizing is crucial. The reviewer initially ordered the wrong size for both boot models and had to exchange them. They found that a US size 12 (UK 11) fits perfectly in the Simms boots, but required a US size 13 (UK 12) in the Orvis boots. This highlights the importance of trying boots on before purchasing.
Ultimately, the reviewer prefers the Orvis Pro BOA boots due to their superior comfort and convenience of the BOA system. While the Simms boots are comfortable, the lacing system and lack of a gaiter clip are drawbacks. The potential release of a Simms G4 with BOA technology warrants further investigation.
