Finding the perfect pair of ice fishing gloves can make or break your day on the ice. With so many options available, choosing the right gloves for your needs can feel overwhelming. This comprehensive guide reviews five top-performing ice fishing gloves for 2024, helping you navigate the market and select the ideal pair for your specific requirements. Whether you're a seasoned angler braving extreme cold or a casual fisherman enjoying milder conditions, we've got you covered. We'll explore key features like waterproofing, insulation, dexterity, and durability, ensuring you find gloves that offer the perfect balance of warmth, comfort, and performance.This review covers a range of options, from budget-friendly choices to high-performance models designed for extreme conditions. We’ll delve into the pros and cons of each glove, providing detailed insights into their construction, features, and overall performance. By the end of this guide, you'll be well-equipped to make an informed decision and confidently choose the best ice fishing gloves to keep your hands warm, dry, and comfortable throughout your next ice fishing adventure.
Pros And Cons
- Budget-friendly price
- Made of waterproof neoprene material
- Textured palm and finger area for good grip
- Fits most men's and women's hands
- Multi-purpose glove for other outdoor activities
- Only available in large and extra-large sizes
- Comfortable and durable for mild winter conditions
- Non-slip microfiber palm
- Smartphone friendly tips
- Adjustable cuffs
- Waterproof material lined with fleece
- Finger slits on thumb, index, and middle finger
- Only good for mildly cool weather
- Good grip on palm area
- Adjustable cuffs for secure fit
- Breathable and windproof material
- Made of stretch neoprene for better fit
- Finger slits for handling phone, etc.
- Not completely waterproof
- Waterproof material
- Touchscreen compatible tips
- Elastic lightener on wrists for comfort
- Breathable and warm insulation (four layers)
- Storage pocket for keys and small items
- Touchscreen feature not very precise
Read more: Unpunctureable: Top 5 Fishing Gloves for Ultimate Protection
Palm Myth Neoprene Fishing Gloves: Best Neoprene Option
For casual ice fishing in moderate conditions, the Palm Myth Neoprene gloves are a great choice. These gloves offer a good balance of dexterity and protection without being overly bulky. The neoprene material provides decent waterproofing and wind resistance, keeping your hands dry and warm. The adjustable cuffs ensure a secure and comfortable fit.
The textured palm provides excellent grip, crucial for handling slippery fish and fishing equipment. While not completely waterproof, they effectively repel moisture and offer adequate protection against the elements. Finger slits allow for easy phone use or manipulating smaller objects.
Overall, these are a reliable and affordable option for anglers who need a balance of warmth, dexterity, and grip without the need for extreme weather protection.
Windrider Rugged Waterproof Winter Gloves: Top Waterproof Pick
If complete waterproofing is your priority, the Windrider Rugged gloves are a top contender. With five layers of protection—waterproof layer, Cordura nylon shell, breathable Hypora liner, Thinsulate, and soft fleece—these gloves offer superior insulation and weather resistance.
The thick construction provides exceptional warmth and comfort, even in harsh winter conditions. Features like touchscreen compatibility on the fingertips, elastic wrist liners, and a storage pocket add to their practicality. The multi-layered design ensures durability and long-lasting performance.
While the touchscreen functionality might not be as precise as dedicated touchscreen gloves, it is still a valuable feature for quick phone checks. These gloves offer excellent all-around protection and comfort for extreme cold.
Memphis Glove N9690FCL: Best Value Ice Fishing Gloves
For budget-conscious anglers, the Memphis Glove N9690FCL offers impressive value. These gloves are surprisingly durable and well-made, providing excellent warmth and dryness when properly maintained (regular washing is recommended).
Treated with HTP liquid repellent and featuring Active Fresh technology to combat bacteria, these gloves stay fresh and functional. They boast a high ANSI cut and abrasion resistance score. Even at extremely low temperatures, the materials remain soft and flexible.
The main drawback is the lack of finger slits, which limits dexterity when dealing with smaller objects. However, if you prioritize warmth, durability, and budget-friendliness, these gloves are a strong choice.
Cast King Mountain Mist Fishing Gloves: Runner-Up Choice
The Cast King Mountain Mist gloves are comfortable and durable for milder winter conditions. They provide adequate warmth and a snug fit thanks to their soft fleece lining. The design is stylish and functional, not just plain.
Features include a non-slip microfiber palm, smartphone-compatible fingertips, and adjustable cuffs. The combination of waterproof material and fleece lining provides decent insulation. Finger splits on the thumb, index, and middle finger enhance dexterity.
However, these gloves are not suitable for extreme cold. Their best use is in milder winter conditions where a balance of comfort and protection is needed.
Big Worm Fishing Men's Neoprene Gloves: Best Overall
The Big Worm Fishing gloves claim the top spot as the best overall. The soft inner lining provides remarkable comfort, while the textured palm ensures a secure grip on rods and slippery fish. The 3mm neoprene offers excellent insulation against cold.
A budget-friendly price point makes them accessible to a wider range of anglers. The textured palm and fingers enhance grip, even in wet conditions. They are versatile enough for various outdoor activities beyond ice fishing.
The limited size availability (large and extra-large) is a minor drawback. However, their comfort, grip, warmth, and affordability make them an outstanding choice for most ice fishermen.
Conclusion: Choosing the Right Ice Fishing Gloves
Selecting the best ice fishing gloves depends on your individual needs and the conditions you'll be facing. For casual ice fishing in moderate conditions, the Palm Myth Neoprene gloves are a practical and affordable choice. If you require complete waterproofing and extreme cold protection, the Windrider Rugged gloves are superior.
The Memphis Glove offers excellent value for money, while the Cast King gloves are ideal for mild winter days. Finally, the Big Worm Fishing gloves emerge as the best overall, balancing comfort, durability, grip, and affordability. Consider your budget, the severity of the weather, and the level of dexterity required to make the best selection.