This review dives deep into the Frogg Toggs 17" Camo Mud Boot (product #2516058), a size 11 boot designed for superior protection and comfort in wet conditions. We'll explore its key features, focusing on the unique combination of materials and construction that sets it apart from other rubber boots. The lightweight design, achieved through a rubber exterior and neoprene interior, is a major highlight, offering a significant improvement in comfort and flexibility compared to heavier alternatives. We'll analyze the boot's durability, traction, and overall fit, comparing its performance to a previously reviewed Hi-Tec model.This detailed assessment will cover the boot's robust rubber exterior, the comfortable and warm neoprene lining, and the standout hiking-boot-style sole with its rigid shank. We will examine the boot's fit around the ankle, noting its ease of use, and discuss the impact of the comfortable rubber/PVC footbed. Ultimately, this review aims to provide a comprehensive evaluation of the Frogg Toggs 17" Camo Mud Boot, helping readers determine if it's the right choice for their needs, based on its strengths in lightweight design, superior construction, and enhanced comfort.
Pros And Cons
- 17 inches tall
- 100% waterproof
- Lightweight
- Rubber overlay over neoprene
- Protective toe (not composite or steel)
- Hiking boot-style sole with good arch support
- Rigid sole that doesn't deform
- Comfortable interior with rubber/PVC footbed
- Loose-fitting ankle for easy on/off
Read more: Top 5 Neoprene Fishing Boots for Ultimate Comfort & Protection
Product Overview & Specifications
The Frogg Toggs 17" Camo Mud Boot (product #2516058) is a size 11 boot that boasts several impressive features. It stands 17 inches tall, offering excellent protection from the elements. The manufacturer highlights its 100% waterproof construction, making it ideal for wet conditions.

One key feature is its lightweight design, a significant improvement over other heavy rubber boots. This lightweight build is achieved through a unique combination of materials: a rubber exterior and neoprene interior. The rubber overlay provides durability, while the neoprene contributes to comfort and flexibility.

Construction and Materials
The boot's construction is a key selling point. The exterior is a durable rubber, offering protection against abrasions and water. The interior is lined with neoprene, a flexible and comfortable material that provides warmth and a snug fit without being restrictive.

This combination of rubber and neoprene makes the boot both durable and comfortable. The reviewer notes a significant difference from a previously reviewed Hi-Tec rubber boot, highlighting the superior construction of this Frogg Toggs model.
Sole and Support
The sole of the Frogg Toggs boot is a standout feature. It's designed with a hiking boot-style tread, providing excellent traction on various terrains. Unlike the previously reviewed Hi-Tec boot, this one has a rigid shank (likely fiberglass or steel), preventing sole deformation and providing superior arch support.

This rigid sole ensures comfort and stability, even on uneven ground. The reviewer demonstrates the rigidity of the sole, showcasing its resistance to bending and flexing. The arch support also contributes to the overall comfort of the boot.

Fit and Comfort
The Frogg Toggs boot features a comfortable, loose fit around the ankle, unlike many other tight-fitting rubber boots. This design makes it easy to put on and take off quickly. The reviewer also notes the comfortable rubber/PVC footbed which contributes greatly to the boot’s comfort.

The overall comfort and ease of use make this a better option for those who prioritize convenience and a less restrictive fit. This is a major improvement over boots with tight ankles, making it much more practical for everyday use.
Final Verdict
The Frogg Toggs 17" Camo Mud Boot offers a significant upgrade from other rubber boots, especially the reviewer's experience with the Hi-Tec boot. The lightweight design, combined with the durable rubber exterior and comfortable neoprene interior, makes for an impressive package.

The rigid sole with excellent arch support provides stability and comfort, while the easy-on/easy-off ankle design adds to its practicality. The reviewer highly recommends these boots, especially considering their lightweight nature and the superior construction compared to other options.