Choosing the right fishing hook can significantly impact your success rate. This review compares two popular hook types – EWG and worm hooks – focusing on their performance across key criteria: strength, sharpness, stickiness, and barb hold. We rigorously tested several leading brands, subjecting them to a series of demanding tests designed to simulate real-world fishing conditions. The results offer valuable insights into the strengths and weaknesses of each hook, helping anglers make informed decisions based on their specific needs and fishing style. Understanding these differences will allow you to select the hook best suited for targeting different species and utilizing various fishing techniques.This comprehensive review analyzes the performance of Googan Hammer, Daiichi, Sticky, VMC, Owner, Gamakatsu, and Prism hooks. Each hook underwent rigorous testing to determine its strength, sharpness, ability to penetrate and hold, and the effectiveness of its barb. By objectively comparing these critical aspects, we've identified top performers and highlighted the subtle but important differences between these popular choices. This detailed analysis empowers anglers to choose the hook that best matches their fishing style and ensures a successful day on the water.
Read more: Top 5 Fishing Hooks You Need
Hook Strength Test
The strength test involved applying pressure to each hook until it bent or broke. This provided a measure of their durability under stress. The results were interesting, showcasing the differences in construction and materials between various hook types.
The Googan Hammer hook surprisingly performed exceptionally well, withstanding an impressive 34 pounds of force before showing any significant damage. This reinforced its reputation for strength and durability. The other hooks, while also strong, exhibited varying degrees of resistance before bending or breaking.
The Daiichi hook showed impressive strength, reaching 26.44 pounds before failure. The Sticky and VMC hooks performed similarly, exceeding 26 pounds. The Owner and Gamakatsu hooks were slightly less robust, breaking around 26-28 pounds.
Hook Sharpness and Stickiness Test
This test evaluated the hooks' sharpness and stickiness by dragging them across sandpaper and paper. The goal was to determine how well they held their edge and how readily they penetrated material, simulating a fish's mouth.
The Daiichi hook proved exceptionally sharp, easily shaving paper and exhibiting remarkable stickiness even after multiple passes on the sandpaper. The Owner hook also maintained its sharpness throughout the test, displaying excellent holding power.
The Sticky and Gamakatsu hooks performed well, but the VMC and Prism hooks dulled more quickly, indicating a less durable sharpness. The Googan hook's unique design provided exceptional penetration and hold.
Barb Hold Test
The barb hold test assessed how well each hook's barb secured its hold. The hooks were inserted into cardboard, and then pulled out to see the resistance of the barbs. This simulated the process of hooking and landing a fish.
The Sticky, Owner, Googan, and Daiichi hooks consistently demonstrated excellent barb hold, resisting removal and even causing damage to the cardboard. The VMC hook also performed well but showed some minor limitations.
The Gamakatsu and Prism hooks showed good barb hold, however, not as strongly as the top performers. The differences in barb design and construction appeared to contribute to the varying levels of hold.
Overall Conclusion and Recommendations
Based on the combined results of the strength, sharpness, stickiness, and barb hold tests, the Googan Hammer hook emerged as the overall winner. Its exceptional strength and penetration made it stand out.
The Daiichi hook was also a top performer, impressing with its sharpness, stickiness, and strength. The Owner hook, despite having slightly lower strength, showed remarkable sharpness and excellent barb hold, making it a strong contender.
The Sticky, VMC, and Gamakatsu hooks all offered good performance but showed minor limitations in sharpness, strength, or barb hold compared to the top three. The Prism hook did not perform as well as the others in the sharpness and stickiness test, but it did show great strength.
