This in-depth comparison analyzes three Daiwa LT spinning reels: the Procyon LT, Tatula LT, and Ballistic LT, all in the popular 2500 size. While sharing a similar core design philosophy emphasizing lightweight construction and smooth performance, subtle differences in construction and materials lead to distinct fishing experiences. We'll delve into a detailed examination of their visual aspects, internal components, and most importantly, how these variations impact the reel's feel and performance during actual fishing.This review covers a comprehensive comparison, dissecting the similarities and differences between the reels. We will explore the nuances of their drag systems, spool designs, and the impact of materials like aluminum and zinc gears. Finally, we'll provide recommendations for choosing the right reel based on your budget and fishing environment, considering factors like freshwater versus saltwater applications and the importance of features like sealed bearings.
Read more: 5 Best Electric Fishing Reels of 2024
Unboxing and Initial Impressions
This review compares three Daiwa reels: the Procyon LT, Tatula LT, and Ballistic LT. All are 2500 size, offering a good balance of power and sensitivity. The Procyon LT, released in 2019, is a newer model. The Tatula LT (2017) and the JDM version of the Tatula LT (also 2017) are included for comparison, highlighting the gear ratios – 6.2:1 for the Procyon, and 5.0:1 for the Tatula LTs, similar to the Diablo reels.
The visual differences were immediately apparent. The reels vary significantly in color and the materials used, particularly around the spool. The overall construction and feel varied between models, particularly the level of perceived smoothness during initial handling.
Bearing Count and Construction
Contrary to some claims, the Procyon LT and Tatula LT have the same number of bearings and are located identically. The discrepancy in Daiwa's specifications regarding corrosion-resistant bearings seems insignificant due to the lack of sealing in both reels. Any water intrusion would compromise all bearings, regardless of corrosion resistance.
A comparison of the anti-reverse clutch bearings and main gear bearings confirmed their similarity. The subtle difference mentioned – a corrosion-resistant bearing in the Tatula – likely resides on the pinion gear, but this bears little practical importance given the lack of seals to protect it.
Key Difference: Spool and Spool Support
The most significant difference lies in the spool and its support structure. The Tatula LT has a colored plastic support under the spool, while the Procyon LT lacks this, resulting in more spool play. This design difference affects the feel of the drag.
The Legolas LT spool fits on both the Procyon LT and Tatula LT, highlighting interchangeable parts. The Procyon LT spool's design—flat bottom versus the colored support—influences its side-to-side movement, leading to a less consistent drag feel compared to the Tatula LT.
Fishing Experience and Reel Feel
In actual fishing scenarios, the Procyon LT felt more like the Legolas LT than the Tatula LT, attributed to the increased spool play and less consistent drag. The Tatula LT provided a crisper, more consistent drag, making it feel more premium.
The Procyon LT and Tatula LT were more rigid due to their Zion carbon bodies, unlike the Legolas LT, which exhibited more flex. This rigidity enhances the overall feel and performance, especially for larger reel sizes.
Gear Material and Durability
The Procyon LT and Tatula LT boast machine-cut aluminum gears, promising smoother performance over time compared to the Legolas LT's cast zinc gears. The long-term smoothness and durability of these components differ between the reels, with the aluminum gears expected to last longer.
This explains why, despite the similarities in other components, the Procyon LT feels closer to the Legolas LT in terms of drag feel, even though it uses more durable components. This discrepancy underscores the importance of the spool design in influencing the overall fishing experience.
Ballistic LT: The Sealed Version
The Daiwa Ballistic LT is essentially a sealed version of the Tatula LT, featuring three additional seals to protect against water intrusion. This added sealing comes at a price increase. The enhanced protection is valuable for saltwater fishing.
The lack of seals in the Procyon LT and Tatula LT makes them unsuitable for saltwater use. This highlights a crucial distinction: while the internal components might be similar, the added sealing significantly impacts the practical usability of the Ballistic LT in various conditions.
Overall Conclusion and Recommendations
All three Daiwa LT reels—Procyon, Tatula, and Ballistic—offer exceptional smoothness and low startup inertia, surpassing other brands. The choice depends on budget and fishing environment.
For saltwater fishing, the sealed Ballistic LT is superior. In freshwater, the Tatula LT offers better drag feel and overall aesthetics for a reasonable price premium over the Procyon LT. If budget is paramount and you are primarily fishing freshwater, the Procyon LT remains a solid option, especially if using a heavier rod.
